By Jason Pike
Is This What Growth Looks Like? A Hard Look at Holy Cross and the Future of Senior Men’s Soccer in Newfoundland
One thing we constantly preach here in Newfoundland is development — in every sport we play. We talk about giving players every opportunity to grow and improve, and soccer is no exception. Over the last decade, clubs across the island have pushed hard to align themselves with professional outfits both overseas and at home, organizing travel trips to higher-level competitions in an effort to raise the standard of play.
Anyone involved in sport in this province knows just how expensive and difficult that can be. We’re geographically isolated, and getting top-tier games often means leaving the island. So yes — development starts at home. It starts with grassroots programs, minor leagues, and senior teams. That’s why what’s happening in senior men’s soccer this summer — specifically in the Challenge Cup — is so disheartening.
Let’s back up for a moment.
The NL Challenge Cup was inaugurated in 1967, following the All-Newfoundland Series (1950–1966). Over that span of time, Holy Cross FC has been a powerhouse — claiming 21 Challenge Cup titles since 1973. Add in their two earlier All-Newfoundland titles from 1950 and 1961, and their total provincial championships stand at 23. There’s no question: they’ve earned their spot in the history books.
But in 2025, something feels off. Something feels broken.
This year, the Challenge Cup league showed real promise — perhaps the most in recent memory — with two brand new clubs joining the fray: St. John’s United and Portugal Cove SC. For the first time in years, the season was longer, the schedule fuller, and the energy high. It finally felt like a turn toward revival for senior soccer in the province.
But then came August 2nd.
Portugal Cove, in its inaugural season, suited up to face Holy Cross. And what unfolded wasn’t just a defeat — it was a demolition. Final score? 25–0.
Let that sink in.
Twenty-five to zero.
There was no excitement, no praise, no applause. Just stunned silence and disbelief across the provincial soccer community. People assumed it was a typo until the score appeared, officially posted, for all to see. This wasn’t development. It wasn’t growth. It was humiliation.
Yes, Holy Cross is dominant. Yes, they’ve got talent and coaching that many admire. But at what point does dominance become damaging? Where is the line between playing to win and pulverizing for pride?
The 2025 squad, assembled by Jake Stanford, has become known as an “unbeatable all-star team.” Their record: 15 wins, 0 losses, a goal differential of +99 (104 for, 5 against). On paper, it’s historic. But on the field — in a league trying to attract and retain new blood — it’s potentially fatal.
Let’s call it what it is: a failure of leadership.
Because this isn’t just about competition. It’s about responsibility — the responsibility to grow the game, not gatekeep it. A club with the legacy and prestige of Holy Cross should be a beacon, not a bully. When you see a team of newcomers struggling, you don’t put your foot on their throat for 90 minutes. You don’t run up the score to 25 goals. You don’t demoralize them so thoroughly that they may never return.
What’s achieved in a result like that? Nothing. You gain no respect. You foster no growth. You only deepen the divide and discourage participation — especially in rural Newfoundland, where the sport has already suffered due to outmigration and economic hardship.
We used to have a league where towns like Burin, Marystown, Lawn, and Grand Bank were regular contenders. That’s been fading. And this year, we had hope. But results like this don’t just set the league back — they set the sport back.
This is a wake-up call.
Because if you truly love this game — if you’re serious about growing it here — then you don’t just chase trophies. You build a league worth playing in. A league that encourages newcomers. That supports development. That knows when to compete and when to teach.
There’s no rule against stacking your roster. There’s no mercy rule. No formal consequences for running up the score. But what we’re losing — quietly and steadily — are the ethics of the game.
If we want Challenge Cup to survive… if we want senior soccer in Newfoundland to thrive… we need to take a hard look at who we’re playing for — and who we’re pushing away.
Because right now, it looks like we’re winning the battle… but losing the game.
~~~
Like what you see? Please put a few dollars in the Tip Jar via PayPal or cards to help keep the Sports Page going. THANK YOU!
For more Newfoundland and Labrador news, stories and photos please visit our sister publication, The Gammy Bird.
